Arizona Attorney Says Sports Betting Would Require Compact Change

The existing Arizona tribal state gaming compacts create an almost insurmountable barrier to the state legislature creating a framework for legalizing sports betting says attorney Steve Hart (l.). Any such framework would violate the compacts and rob the state of much of the gaming revenue they pay, say experts in gaming and Indian law.

Gaming and Indian law attorney Stephen Hart, a partner with Lewis Roca Rothgerber Christie LLC said in a speech last week that if Arizona approves sports betting, it will need to offer a deal to the state’s 20 gaming tribes or risk losing at least some existing gaming revenue.

There has been some discussion of allowing businesses or even the state itself to offer sports betting. However, Hart told a forum on sports betting held at Arizona State University that this risks violating the tribal state gaming compacts.

Hart predicted that probably sports gaming in Arizona will be limited to casinos operated by gaming tribes. “That’s probably the way you’re going to see it here in Arizona,” Hart said. He added that it would be almost impossible for the state to pass a sports betting law that would open it up to commercial vendors—but not tribes.

One speaker asserted that Arizona’s gaming compacts, first adopted in 2002, are currently under negotiation to allow sports betting. If they are, so far no progress has been announced.

The state’s problem is frequently described as a “poison pill,” that affects states that having gaming compacts with tribes. Without an almost complete rewrite, the state would probably lose more money than it would make. The tribes currently pay 8 percent of their gaming revenue to the state in return for exclusivity.

Hart said the state would need to limit taxation to 7 to 10 percent, or it would encourage illegal sports betting.

Recent Articles

History Playbook

On This Day In Sports History

On August 23, 2017, Dodgers starter Rich Hill lost both a no-hitter and the game on a single pitch in a 1-0 loss to the Pirates at PNC Park. Hill carried a perfect game into the 9th inning before an error broke it up, though he retired the next three batters to keep the no-hitter intact. Returning for the 10th inning in a scoreless tie, Hill surrendered a walk-off home run on a 2-1 pitch to Pittsburgh leadoff hitter Josh Harrison.

On This Day In Sports History

On August 22, 1951, St. Louis Browns pitcher Tommy Byrne tied a major league record by issuing 16 walks in a 3-1, 13-inning loss to the Boston Red Sox at Sportsman's Park. Byrne faced 63 batters, struck out five, left 22 men on base, and even drove in St. Louis's only run with a fifth-inning double. Boston secured the victory in the top of the 13th behind a Ted Williams single and four two-out walks, including a bases-loaded pass to opposing pitcher Leo Kiely, who pitched 12 1/3 innings for the win.